Log in
Free: The Observer Mobile App - Exclusive Content and Services

Will TV adaptation redeem Robert Jordan’s Wheel Of Time?

Wheel of Time is an epic fantasy series of novels that Robert Jordan started in 1990 and Brandon Sanderson finished in 2013. Now we are getting an Amazon TV adaptation and people cannot stop screaming about the casting choices.

The 14 WoT novels are very divisive. For some people, Robert Jordan wrote the greatest fantasy series in literary history. But I don’t want to talk about those people today. Let us look at the other side instead; those readers for whom Robert Jordan is only second to Terry Goodkind. And in case you are not in the know, fantasy readers HATE Terry Goodkind.

I want to talk about all the hate Wheel of Time gets. These are just some of the explanations I was able to glean from passionate detractors of the series. First of all, the Wheel of Time has such drastic shifts in quality.

The first five books in the series are actually quite strong, so much so that most readers would not have batted an eye if Book Six or even Seven had failed to reach the bar raised by their predecessors.

But what happened was even worse; not only were books six and seven dull as paint, books eight, nine and 10 were so bad they killed the series for many fans. We can all forgive an author that fumbles a book or two. But five books?

Keep in mind that each of those books is over 1,000 pages long. And that is just one foible. You also have the fact that Jordan was constantly opening new plot threads and abandoning them; important characters would disappear for several books at a time.

That is not even accounting for the clichés. Rand is what we call a Gary Sue. He’s just too damn powerful. Mat and Perrin, the best friends that should have grounded him, basically stumble their way through one lucky break after another, notching victories and reputations they do not necessarily work for.

The plot relies so heavily on the ‘Chosen One’ factor. The names get harder and harder to pronounce with each new character Jordan introduces, and the women are simply atrocious.

In fact, Jordan’s female characters are probably his biggest shame. First of all, most of them are thoroughly unlikable. Secondly, their lives are seemingly ruled by their lustful obsession with Rand and his friends.

Thirdly, they are so catty towards one another, mostly because of jealousy and envy; mostly because they all want Rand’s body; mostly because he’s the chosen one.

Suffice it to say, there are people who would not touch Wheel of Time for all the money in the world. And I can’t help but wonder whether the TV show starring Rosamund Pike among others,will remain faithful to the books, or if the showrunners will make alterations to appease the fans that fell off.  I know quite a few people who hated Game of Thrones the book series but love Game of Thrones the TV show. Excluding the final season, obviously.



+4 #1 Mike 2019-09-21 06:17
While there is at time some truth to what you wrote, describing the female characters in these books as all wanting Rand's body is either disingenuous (if you've read them), or ignorant (if you haven't).

There are 5 (4 1/2 really) women who go after Rand out of a cast of literally hundreds of named female characters.

Those characters, even if they are unlikeable to some, are deeply developed, fully fleshed out people. Just food for thought.
Report to administrator
+4 #2 ht_Frank 2019-09-21 13:30
What, who thinks book 6 is a low point? Even book 7 isn't bad by any standards only a little worse than 4-6.

Yes, book 8-10 drag the story because Jordan introduced too many subplots (that he doesn't abandon). If some aren't solved at the end of the story it has more do with the fact that another author sadly needed to end the saga.

I like many of the female and the male characters of the story (because they are well developed I even like to read about the ones that aren't my favorites – an no: must of the females aren't in love with the protagonist) and the protagonist surely isn't a Gary sue like a certain Goodkind character. He is very powerful in later books but has many flaws that he needs to overcome.
Report to administrator
+2 #3 Starr 2019-09-22 17:53
I dont think I read the same books as you. I didn't care for Rand, but it had to do with the fact that he had TOO MANY flaws and it drove me up the wall. Mat was supposed to be lucky. It's his whole thing. Perrin doesn't luck into much. He earns it and loses almost everything in the process. The pattern literally bends around them, which is why these things happen.

As for the women, one 3 are after Rand. And one more is a little obsessed with him (for her own reasons). All the women in this series are POWERFUL women. Maybe some have to see that as a fatal flaw. Egwene is not interested in any of the boys, and she is a very career minded young woman.

Yes, a few books in the middle were a little slow, but the series is 14 books. That's like 1 book in a trilogy.

I am pretty sure this person either didn't read the books or read something I didn't. Because none of this is accurate.
Report to administrator
+2 #4 Koronin 2019-09-24 18:45
Lord of Chaos dull? Oy
Report to administrator

Comments are now closed for this entry